Castaway Tips

Welcome to the Castaway tips page! On this page you’ll find tips and tutorials for making your own Castaway top. Below are the list of tips and tutorials you’ll find here:

Picking a Size

Castaway is a drop-shoulder top and this means you typically want to pick a size whose finished circumference has more positive ease than you may typically have in a sweater (new to the term ‘positive ease’? Read my post here!). For this pattern, I generally recommend picking a size that is 6-10″ larger than your actual bust measurement. For example, if you are a 34″ bust, then I would recommend you knit the size small which has a finished circumference of 43″ as that will give you 9″ of positive ease.

However, if you prefer a closer-fit (or more oversized), feel free to pick a size that matches your desired finished look. Just one thing to keep in mind – if you pick a size with not a lot of positive ease (say, only 2-5″ of positive ease), you will want to add a bit more length to your armhole depth. For more information about this as well as other tips when it comes to picking a size in drop-shoulder tops, check out my blog post here!

Importance of Fiber Content When Picking a Yarn

Picking a yarn is very important in this piece as the type of fiber you use will impact whether or not I recommend making some adjustments. I knit the original Castaway in Berroco Quinoa, a cotton/nylon DK-weight blend. Because it’s a cotton blend (with no wool), I was able to keep the edges “raw”. This means there is no kind of trim added on the hem, neckline or sleeve cuffs – it’s just plain stockinette stitch. When edges are left raw in a cotton/linen/hemp yarn it’s fine because it tends to stay pretty flat (or you can steam it flat and it stays that way).

But if you were to use a yarn with wool in it, these raw edges wouldn’t stay flat, no matter what you do! Wool has a lot more elasticity to it than cotton or linen so when you work an edge in Stockinette Stitch with it, it gets all springy and just wants to roll. I also find that 100% cotton can have this tendency as well (vs a cotton mixed with nylon, polyster or linen, at least in my experience!).

So if you want to knit this design but use a yarn with wool in it, I recommend using the following types of stitch patterns as your trim:

  • Garter Stitch (when worked in the round as you would do in this design, that means knitting 1 round, then purling 1 round and repeating those 2 rounds for 1-2″).
  • Rib Stitch (working k1,p1 all across the round and then repeating that round for 1-2″)
  • Broken Rib Stitch (working k1,p1 all across the round, followed by a round where you knit across the round, then repeating these 2 rnds for 1-2″)

And then I would recommend using this trim in the following areas:


This is pretty easy to do for the body hem and the sleeve hems. For the body, just work the beginning of the pattern in the trim pattern for 1-2″ (right after cast-on) and then transition to Stockinette stitch and work until measures the amount of inches specified in the pattern. For the sleeves it’s similar – work in Stockinette stitch until 1-2″ before your desired length and then transition to your trim pattern for the remaining length.


For the neck opening edge, it’s slightly different. You would have to use a 16″ circular and pick up and knit all of the stitches around the neck opening after the garment is all done. You would pick up and knit into each of the back neck stitches, and then along each front ‘curve’ you would pick up approx. 3 sts for every 4 rows, and then pick up and knit into each of the center front cast-on stitches. If you are doing a k1,p1 rib stitch pattern you would just need to make sure the total amount of stitches picked up was a multiple of 2. I’d also recommend that you use 1 needle size smaller than you used for the body of the garment.

And that’s it! Just a few modifications and your Castaway is ready for wool and a more cold-weather friendly top. Would you like to see a great example? Below is a photo shared with me from Charlene who added trim to her own Castaway because she knit it in Elsebeth Lavold Silky Wool, a wool/silk/nylon blend:

Castaway knit by Charlene in Silky Wool yarn.

She added broken rib stitch to the bottom hem and sleeve edges, and then garter stitch the neck trim. I love how this came out and hopefully it helps you to envision what yours may look like as well should you add trim.

Yarn Substitution Ideas

As of the last update of this page (February 2022), Berroco Quinoa has been discontinued. But, I have some other yarn substitution ideas that knit up similarly to Quinoa, including some new yarns that Berroco just came out with for Spring/Summer 2022:

  • Berroco Meraki: this is a cotton/polyester/hemp blend that knits up so similiarly to Quinoa (even a similar thick/thin texture). In my swatching, the only difference was that in the Meraki I had to go down to a US 5 needle (instead of US 6). And like the Quinoa, the edges had minimal rolling
  • Berroco Isola: this is a cotton/linen/viscose blend and is also a great option to consider. Similar to Meraki, I had to go down a needle size to get gauge and I also found in my swatching it had minimal rolling.
  • Juniper Moon Farm Zooey DK: this is a cotton/linen blend that’s a great option to consider. It also has a similiar thick and thin texture like Quinoa, and I was able to get gauge on the same US 6 needle.

There are so many other DK yarn options out there to consider! Just keep in mind my notes above about fiber content and adding a trim stitch pattern if needed.

Remember, swatching is important!
Regardless of what yarn you may choose to use, remember to swatch (and make sure to swatch in the round) because everyone’s tension can be a little bit different (and for more tips about gauge, read the next section). Plus, swatching will help to show you how much your raw edges may roll (and so it will tell you whether or not you should consider adding a trim to the hem and other edges!). Let me show you an example…

Below you will see a swatch I did in Berroco Meraki, a cotton/polyester/hemp blend (pink yarn) as well as a swatch in Berroco Spree, a wool/cotton blend (multi-color). In the pre-blocked picture, you can see how Meraki’s cast-on and bind-off edges (the top and bottom) have hardly any roll (even before blocking!) whereas Spree is rolling so much you can’t even tell it’s a little swatch. After blocking the Meraki looks similar to pre-blocked (perhaps a little flatter on the edges) and Spree has de-rolled a little bit, but you can still see it rolls and probably will continue to roll more.

So swatching will not only help you figure out what needle size you should be using (to make sure you are close to gauge) but it will also tell you whether or not your chosen yarn will work for the raw edge design. If your swatch looks like Spree’s did above, simply work my suggestions for adding trim and you’ll be good to go!

Adjusting for a slightly different gauge

In Castaway, the stitch gauge is more important than row gauge, so focus on trying to match that when you’re swatching. But, if your gauge is a bit off, not to worry. Castaway’s silhouette and construction is so simple that there are workarounds if you have a different gauge.

Option 1: Your sweater comes out a little bigger or smaller.

If let’s say you’re getting a gauge of 20 sts = 4″ instead of 21 sts = 4″, then your sweater will come out around 2″ larger in total circumference (or 1″ wider on either side). In some sweaters this may seem dramatic but in a drop-shoulder garment where you’re picking a size whose finished measurement is 6-10″ larger than your actual bust, 3″ isn’t super dramatic. Same goes if your gauge is a bit tighter. Let’s say you’re getting a gauge of 22 sts = 4″, then your sweater will be 2″ smaller in total circumference. So long as you were originally in the middle or upper part of that 6-10″ range, this shouldn’t be a problem. But if your gauge is more off or if you think the change will make your sweater too big or too small, read option 2 below.

Option 2: Follow the instructions for a different size.

You can simply knit a size smaller or size larger to accommodate a looser or tighter gauge. Let’s say your gauge is 20 sts = 4″. And let’s say you have an actual bust of 38″. You had originally wanted to make the Medium size which has a finished circumference of 47.5″, giving you 9.5″ of positive ease. You take the cast-on number for that size (which is 250) and divide it by your per inch stitch gauge which is 5, and you get a measurement of 50″. But for your bust size you feel that is too big – so then take the next size down’s cast-on number (which is 226) and divide that by 5 and you get a measurement of 45.25″. This is about 2″ less than the medium size you were originally aiming for, but for your bust size of 38″, it still gives you over 7″ of positive ease which is in the recommended range. So by knitting the size Small at your gauge, you’ll get a size that will work for you and not be too oversized.

Video Tutorials for Techniques:

– Long-Tail Cast-on & Joining to Work in the Round

If you are new to this type of cast-on, check out my basic video tutorial here. Also, you can watch this video tutorial where I show you how I join to work in the round when I have a lot of stitches (like in a sweater body) – I was demo-ing a different sweater but the idea/technique is the same regardless of the designs.

– Cable Cast-on

The cable cast-on is worked when you cast-on stitches for your Front underarms. Check out this video tutorial where I show you how to work this technique in a similar sweater design (please note that in this demo I cast-on less stitches than in Castaway, but the technique is the same).

– Wrap & Turn Short Rows

Short rows are used to shape the shoulders. For the basics on how to work wrap and turn short rows, check out my video tutorial here. And then watch this video that shows you how to knit (and purl) the wraps as you reach them when you’re done working the short rows.

Note: if you’re interested in substituting German Short Rows, watch my video here.

– Sloped Bind-Off for Neck Shaping

When shaping the neck, I use the “sloped bind-off” technique – the pattern walks you how to do this step by step but if you need a visual, you can watch this video tutorial – it’s for a different sweater but the technique is the same regardless of the specific design.

– Back Underarm Pick-Up

When it comes time to work your upper back (starting at the underarm), you’ll be instructed to pick-up and knit into the base of the Front’s underarm cast-on stitches. Watch this video tutorial for a visual of this process (it was for a different sweater with a different number of stitches being picked-up, but the techniques is the same).

– Three Needle Bind-Off

For a beginner’s video of how to work the three needle bind-off, watch this video tutorial here. You can also watch this video where I demonstrate it on a sweater very similar to Castaway.

– Picking Up Stitches Around Armhole

To create your sleeves, stitches are picked-up around each armhole. You can watch this video tutorial that shows you how to do this in a similar sweater design using the ‘magic loop method’ (which involves using a long circular instead of DPNs). If you want to use DPNs, you can still refer to that video for how to pick-up and knit (you’ll just use DPNs instead of the circular).

– Blocking

Are you new to blocking garments? If so, check out my video tutorial here – I use a different sweater as my example but the technique is the same.